route99west.com

Back to Contents

The Addendum

"I tried to write shorter

but I ran out of time"

~Mark Twain

 



route99west.com/addendum
is an occasional journal of Oregon, from arts and books to public policy & transportation.


All content © 2006- by Alexander B. Craghead, except where otherwise noted.

 Powered by Blogger

 OrBlogs Listed



Feeds & Etc

 Atom Feed

 RSS Feed

 Add to Technorati Favorites



Quick Subject Jump

Book Reviews



Previous Posts

Online slideshow navigation

Another one bites the dust?

Jaguar's 21st Century Gamble

Thoughts on Railfan Publishing

Trams! Trams! Trams!

Grammar Nazis, Unite!

Privatization and Public Infrastructure

Chris' other blog....

New article published

Thanks Jim!



Other Notable Blogs

Cafe Unknown
Travel, History and Portland Oregon by Dan Haneckow

Jack Bog's Blog
By Jack Bogdanski of Portland, Oregon. (Like he needs any other introduction by now? -- A.B.C.)

For Portlanders Only
"Why buy a mattress anywhere else?"

Good Stuff NW
Featuring stuff that is good in the NW

LOST Magazine
LOST Magazine is an online monthly magazine that combines elements of many other literary, online, and national magazines with a singular mission--to reclaim in writing lost people, places, and things.

Mapes on Politics
Way West of the Beltway

Outside Is America
A journal about photography, roadtrips, trains and life, with occasional detours into movies, baseball, music, family and more.

The Photographers' Railroad Page
Good photos usually have good stories to go with them.... The goal of The Photographers' Railroad Page is to provide an outlet for top quality photographs and their story.

Portland Food & Drink
Throwing Ourselves on the Grenade of Bad Food to Save You

Portland Transport Blog
A Conversation About Access & Mobility in the Portland/Vancouver Region

PowellsBooks.Blog
Authors, readers, critics, media -- and booksellers

Rambling West
The musings of a farmer with a typewriter and camera

Stumptown Confidential
Documenting Portland, Oregon architecture, history, and culture through photos, postcards, and words.

The Unauthorized Observer
Observations on faith, photography, trains, baseball, the city where I live (Fullerton, Calif.), anything that I find funny (a lot of things) or irritating (some things) and various incidents involving friends and family.

Under the Weather
...the open road, fatherhood, family life, music, railroads, photography, popular and unpopular culture, sex, violence, religion, the oppression of consumerism and capitalism and the general bullshit that makes up modern life.

Urban Planning Overlord
A blog to counter the myths, lies, and demagoguery others use against sound city planning to further their own ends, fair and foul - but also to urge the profession itself to pull back from the occasional wretched PC exces.

VanPortlander
Living in Vancouver; working in Portland. I have some thoughts.

Whiskey, Texas
...life and experiences in Texas and the Southwest. Recurring themes: Photography, railroads, fading ads / ghost signs, fallen-flag railroad logos, boxcars, bicycling, Texas music, pop culture, sports, road trips, literature, kids and family.

World Scott
The Travel Writing and Photography of Scott Lothes


Blegs & Bargains

 Amazon Book Wishlist

 B&H Wishlist

 My eBay Listings



 Powell's Books Wishlist

   


Monday, July 2, 2007


Cult of the Amateur

The New York Times this weekend published a review of Andrew Keen's new book, The Cult of the Amateur: How Today's Internet is Killing our Culture. (If the times asks you for a registration to read it, just go to http://www.bugmenot.com/view/www.nytimes.com and get a login set.)

Although the title alone suggests this will be an anti-digital rant bordering on the luddite, Keen's theory merits a second glance. Although he takes a few swipes at one of my favorite projects, Wikipedia, he makes a strong case for the gradual replacement of quality content with simple quantity. As Times reviewer Michiko Kakutani summarizes, Keen fears a destruction of truth:

"Postings about political candidates, for instance, can be made by opponents disguising their motives; and propaganda can be passed off as news or information. For that matter, as Mr. Keen points out, the idea of objectivity is becoming increasingly passé in the relativistic realm of the Web, where bloggers cherry-pick information and promote speculation and spin as fact. Whereas historians and journalists traditionally strived to deliver the best available truth possible, many bloggers revel in their own subjectivity, and many Web 2.0 users simply use the Net, in Mr. Keen’s words, to confirm their “own partisan views and link to others with the same ideologies.” What’s more, as mutually agreed upon facts become more elusive, informed debate about important social and political issues of the day becomes more difficult as well."

This subject is near and dear to my heart, and has become a centerpiece of some of my academic writing. In a paper entitled "Kuze's Theorem: New Media & The Emerging Solipsism", I pointed to a very similar effect:
"The "democratization" of media through the establishment of websites, blogs, and so forth has enabled cults, extremists, and partisans at the expense of the more moderate, homogenized "traditional" media. This has created a networked society where whatever "news" an individual finds and likes can become for them a truth just as valid as any other -- even if it's no more than propaganda. We are in danger of losing ourselves in a sea of media "choice", of enveloping our society into fragmentary fits of what is known as solipsism."

To hear these thoughts voiced and given attention in the Gray Lady certainly makes me feel a bit more secure. But to what avail? How many of the Myspace-friendster-Second Life-Facebook-Yahoo!-orkut-etc.... addicts will read it, and how many that do will care? What Keen is pointing out he is framing as some kind of social ill, implying that there is some action that can be taken to counter it. I view it more as a force of nature, as a kind of human tide. Keen seems to position himself as a modern King Canute, setting his thrown at the shore and ordering the tide back. Me I'm scrambling for some wood to build a raft with.

Labels: , ,

Posted By ABC at |

Back to Top | Back to Contents



0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home